Extra Cheese Dream Pizza
Cheese Pizzas · Easy

Extra Cheese Dream Pizza

A deliberately excessive 330 g cheese pizza that still bakes cleanly because melt, moisture, salt and placement are controlled instead of dumped into one pile.

⬇ Jump to Recipe
25 minActive
1 hRest / preheat
10 minCook / bake
1 h 35 minTotal
MediumDifficulty
← Back to Cheese Pizzas
Extra Cheese Dream Pizza

Why this formula works

Three hundred and thirty grams of cheese is genuinely indulgent, but each cheese has a job. Mozzarella stretches, provolone and Fontina flow, Gruyère and cheddar deepen flavor, Pecorino seasons, while Brie and cream cheese remain visible creamy accents. A 280 g dough ball and only 80 g thick béchamel provide enough structure without making this heavy pizza dry.

Honest timing

Active preparation25 min
Hydration / proof / preheat1 h
Cooking / baking10 min
Elapsed total1 h 35 min

Ingredients

  • mature room-temperature pizza dough ball280 g (9.9 oz)
  • cold, thick béchamel80 g (2.82 oz)
  • low-moisture mozzarella, coarsely grated70 g (2.47 oz)
  • mild provolone, coarsely grated40 g (1.41 oz)
  • Fontina, rind removed and coarsely grated40 g (1.41 oz)
  • Gruyère, finely grated35 g (1.23 oz)
  • mature cheddar, coarsely grated35 g (1.23 oz)
  • Pecorino Romano, finely grated25 g (0.88 oz)
  • Brie, chilled and sliced 4 mm thick50 g (1.76 oz)
  • full-fat cream cheese, chilled35 g (1.23 oz)
  • coarsely ground black pepper1 g

Equipment

  • pizza steel or stone
  • pizza peel
  • digital scale
  • coarse and fine graters
  • two chilled bowls
  • pizza wheel

Exact method

  1. 1. Preheat a steel or stone on the lower-middle rack at maximum heat for 60 minutes. Keep Brie and cream cheese refrigerated while preparing the other cheeses.
  2. 2. Coarsely grate mozzarella, provolone, Fontina and cheddar. Finely grate Gruyère and Pecorino. Spread any visibly damp cheese on a clean towel for 10 minutes.
  3. 3. Mix the six grated cheeses with half the black pepper. Do not compact the mixture; loose strands leave steam channels and melt more evenly.
  4. 4. Open the 280 g dough to 30 cm with a defined 1.5–2 cm rim. Move it to a lightly dusted peel and confirm it slides.
  5. 5. Spread 80 g cold béchamel in a thin layer to within 1.5 cm of the rim. It should hold ridges from the spoon rather than flow.
  6. 6. Scatter the grated-cheese blend evenly, keeping the center no thicker than the outer topping zone. Add Brie slices with gaps between them.
  7. 7. Place cream cheese in 10–12 small chilled dollops. Large spoonfuls stay cold while surrounding cheese overcooks.
  8. 8. Bake at 250–300°C / 482–572°F for 7–10 minutes, rotating once. If the top needs more color, use the broiler only after the underside is browned.
  9. 9. Rest on a rack for 2 minutes so the cheese matrix settles. Finish with remaining black pepper and cut into eight smaller slices.

Bake it with the oven you have

A baking steel is useful, not mandatory. If you do not own one, turn a heavy uncoated metal sheet upside down and preheat it fully; the flat hot back becomes the launch surface. A stone or pizza oven also works when its floor temperature is matched to the topping load.

SetupTemperaturePreheatBake timePull it when
Baking steel250–285°C / 482–545°F60 min7–10 minUse the lower-middle rack and rotate once; the loaded center must lift without bending.
Preheated inverted sheetMaximum heat, usually 240–270°C / 464–518°F45 min9–13 minUse a heavy uncoated sheet upside down; keep toppings evenly spread and finish with top heat only after the base sets.
Stone / pizza oven300–350°C / 572–662°F floorHeat until floor and dome are stable4–6 minUse a slightly lower floor than for Neapolitan pizza and turn every 30–45 seconds so the heavy topping heats through.

Recipe-specific order: Keep the ingredient order from the exact method above; changing ovens changes heat and time, not the topping sequence.

How to know it is ready

  • The underside is deeply browned and supports the heavy topping.
  • Cheese is fully molten with small golden blisters, not a separated orange oil lake.
  • Brie and cream cheese remain distinguishable from the grated blend.
  • The center settles after two minutes but remains soft and stretchy.

Troubleshooting

  • Grease pool: cheese was piled in the center or overheated after it had already melted.
  • Pale, soft base: use the full preheat and a 280 g dough ball; do not add more sauce.
  • Rubbery cheese: it baked too long; pull when the base is ready and only small blisters appear.
  • Overly salty: weigh Pecorino and choose mild provolone; do not add salt automatically.

How to adapt the base recipe

  • If one cheese is unavailable, replace it by function: Fontina with young Gouda, provolone with low-moisture mozzarella, or Gruyère with Comté. Keep total grated cheese unchanged.
  • For a slightly lighter version, remove Brie and cream cheese and reduce the total topping by 85 g; it becomes a different, less creamy formula.
  • For 35 cm, use a 340 g dough ball, 105 g béchamel and about 420 g total cheese, distributed just as evenly.

Storage and food safety

This pizza is best shared immediately. Refrigerate within 2 hours for up to 3 days. Reheat uncovered in a hot skillet or oven until the center is steaming; a microwave separates fat and softens the base.

Allergens

Gluten (wheat), Milk

Always verify every label and cross-contact risk; brand formulations can change.

Technical references

Rate this recipe

Rate the recipe after trying it. Your vote helps other home cooks choose and improve the recipe.

Loading ratings ...