Premium Roasted-Tomato BBQ Sauce
Sauces, Dressings & Spreads · Ingredient Guide

Premium Roasted-Tomato BBQ Sauce

Roasted tomatoes, pepper, onion and garlic with vinegar, mustard, tamari and smoked paprika. A thick BBQ pizza sauce.

Jump to Recipe☆ Rate this recipe
1 hr 31 min–2 hr 9 minApproximate elapsed time
All Ingredient Guides

Why this recipe works

High-heat roasting removes excess water and creates browned vegetable flavors before reduction begins. Vinegar, mustard and tamari balance the natural sweetness, while smoked paprika supports rather than replaces the roast.

Timing for this recipe

Preheat alongside preparation20–30 min
Prepare ingredients15–20 min
Roast in the oven35–45 min
Combine and adjust texture4–6 min
Reduce15–25 min
Allow to cool15–20 min
Season and finish2–3 min
Approximate elapsed time1 hr 31 min–2 hr 9 min

These times include the work and rests described here. Temperature, equipment and ripeness can make things quicker or slower.

Heat the oven during the preparation or rest. If it still needs longer, add that extra time.

Ingredients

15 servings · 1× original recipe

Original yield/size: about 500 ml / 2 cups

The ingredient list shows the totals for this selection. Amounts per item stay the same.

  • ripe plum tomatoes, halved800 g (28.2 oz)
  • red bell pepper, seeded and cut into chunks180 g (6.3 oz)
  • yellow onion, cut into wedges150 g (5.3 oz)
  • garlic cloves, unpeeled15 g (0.53 oz)
  • olive oil20 g (0.71 oz)
  • soft brown sugar50 g (1.76 oz)
  • apple cider vinegar50 g (1.76 oz)
  • Dijon or medium mustard15 g (0.53 oz)
  • tamari soy sauce, certified gluten-free if required15 g (0.53 oz)
  • smoked paprika3 g (0.11 oz)
  • fine sea salt, divided8 g (0.28 oz)
  • freshly ground black pepper1 g

Equipment

  • rimmed roasting tray
  • blender or immersion blender
  • wide heavy saucepan
  • fine sieve, optional
  • clean 600 ml jar

Exact method

The pans and vessels listed fit the original quantity. For more servings, plan enough vessels at the same filling depth and prepare each batch as described. Do not multiply cooking times by the number of servings. Look for the doneness cues in the recipe.

  1. Arrange tomatoes and vegetables on a tray Heat the oven to 220°C conventional. Spread tomatoes, pepper, onion and unpeeled garlic on a tray with the oil and 5g salt.
  2. Roast the vegetables until browned Roast for 35–45 minutes until the tomatoes collapse and the vegetables have browned edges. Remove blackened, bitter patches.
  3. Blend the roasted vegetables and pan juices Squeeze garlic from its skin. Blend the vegetables and collected juices smooth, then transfer to a wide saucepan.
  4. Add seasonings and reduce uncovered Add sugar, vinegar, mustard, tamari, smoked paprika and pepper. Simmer uncovered for 15–25 minutes, stirring more often as it thickens.
  5. Check the spoon trail and taste Draw a spoon through the sauce: the trail should remain briefly visible. Taste a cooled sample and use the remaining 3g salt only as needed.
  6. Cool the sauce before topping Cool before topping pizza. This roasted sauce is concentrated; use less than you would use of thin passata.

Estimated nutrition

The estimate treats 500 mL of thick sauce as about 600 g. The yield depends on how far you reduce it.

What is included
  • Dijon mustard
  • Where a label reports an upper limit, the estimate uses that limit.
Nutrient1 serving (about 40 g)Whole batch
Energy45 kcal668 kcal
Protein0.8 g12 g
Carbohydrate6.9 g102.8 g
Fat1.6 g23.5 g
Salt0.73 g11.01 g

Using this component well

Roasting creates the flavour

Spread vegetables with space between them. An overcrowded deep dish collects juice and steams tomatoes. Remove garlic skins and bitter black patches before blending.

Weigh after reducing

Use roughly 60–90 g finished sauce as a starting point for 30 cm. Raw vegetable weight does not tell you how much water remains. Freeze portions; roasting and bottling do not make this shelf-stable.

Allergens

Mustard, Soy Depending on the selected product, may also contain: Sulphites.

Always verify every label and cross-contact risk; brand formulations can change.

Rate this guide

Rate the guide after trying it. Your vote helps other home cooks choose.

Loading ratings …

Comments are optional. By submitting a comment, you consent to public display of your text and any name you provide; you may withdraw this consent at any time for the future. The text is sent to OpenAI for abuse screening. Privacy and deletion.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, but drain them well and roast the solids with the other vegetables; the flavor will be less fresh but still concentrated.
The 30–40 minute roast, blending and 18–25 minute reduction are real elapsed stages. The old 60-minute claim did not cover the full process reliably.
Replace tamari with 10 g gluten-free Worcestershire sauce, but that introduces fish; otherwise add a little more salt and accept less savory depth.

If you like this combination

Guidance for the key steps

Plan the rest of pizza night

Premium Roasted-Tomato BBQ Sauce

Selected quantity: 15 servings

Original yield: about 500 ml / 2 cups

15 servings · 1× original recipe

The ingredient list shows the totals for this selection. Amounts per item stay the same.

The pans and vessels listed fit the original quantity. For more servings, plan enough vessels at the same filling depth and prepare each batch as described. Do not multiply cooking times by the number of servings. Look for the doneness cues in the recipe.

Ingredients

  • ripe plum tomatoes, halved800 g (28.2 oz)
  • red bell pepper, seeded and cut into chunks180 g (6.3 oz)
  • yellow onion, cut into wedges150 g (5.3 oz)
  • garlic cloves, unpeeled15 g (0.53 oz)
  • olive oil20 g (0.71 oz)
  • soft brown sugar50 g (1.76 oz)
  • apple cider vinegar50 g (1.76 oz)
  • Dijon or medium mustard15 g (0.53 oz)
  • tamari soy sauce, certified gluten-free if required15 g (0.53 oz)
  • smoked paprika3 g (0.11 oz)
  • fine sea salt, divided8 g (0.28 oz)
  • freshly ground black pepper1 g

Allergens

Mustard, Soy Depending on the selected product, may also contain: Sulphites. Always verify every label and cross-contact risk; brand formulations can change.

Estimated nutrition

Nutrition1 serving (about 40 g)Selected quantity
Energy45 kcal668 kcal
Protein0.8 g12 g
Carbohydrate6.9 g102.8 g
Fat1.6 g23.5 g
Salt0.73 g11.01 g

Method

  1. Arrange tomatoes and vegetables on a tray Heat the oven to 220°C conventional. Spread tomatoes, pepper, onion and unpeeled garlic on a tray with the oil and 5g salt.
  2. Roast the vegetables until browned Roast for 35–45 minutes until the tomatoes collapse and the vegetables have browned edges. Remove blackened, bitter patches.
  3. Blend the roasted vegetables and pan juices Squeeze garlic from its skin. Blend the vegetables and collected juices smooth, then transfer to a wide saucepan.
  4. Add seasonings and reduce uncovered Add sugar, vinegar, mustard, tamari, smoked paprika and pepper. Simmer uncovered for 15–25 minutes, stirring more often as it thickens.
  5. Check the spoon trail and taste Draw a spoon through the sauce: the trail should remain briefly visible. Taste a cooled sample and use the remaining 3g salt only as needed.
  6. Cool the sauce before topping Cool before topping pizza. This roasted sauce is concentrated; use less than you would use of thin passata.