New York Cheese Pizza with Foldable Slices
Illustration (AI)
Pizza recipes

New York Cheese Pizza with Foldable Slices

Two large cheese pizzas with their own 24-hour cold-fermented dough, a thin tomato layer and low-moisture mozzarella, for a home-oven stone or steel.

Jump to recipe ☆ Rate this recipe
27 hr 6 min–28 hr 9 minApproximate elapsed time

Timing for this recipe

Includes dough preparation, 24 hours of refrigeration and both pizzas. Preheat the steel during the final hour of proofing. The two bakes are sequential; do not top the second pizza while the first bakes.

Preheat alongside preparation45 min–1 hr
Prepare ingredients5–7 min
Mix and shape7–9 min
Proof the covered dough45 min–1 hr
Cold-ferment the dough24 hr
Shape dough balls5–7 min
Relax the dough1 hr 30 min–2 hr
Open and top the first pizza7–10 min
Bake the first pizza10–13 min
Let the surface recover and top the second pizza4–5 min
Bake the second pizza10–13 min
Rest briefly3–5 min
Approximate elapsed time27 hr 6 min–28 hr 9 min

These times include the work and rests described here. Temperature, equipment and ripeness can make things quicker or slower.

Heat the oven during the preparation or rest. If it still needs longer, add that extra time.

Ingredients

2 pizzas · 1× original recipe

Original yield/size: 2 pizzas, each 33–35 cm / 13–14 in

The ingredient list shows the totals for this selection. Amounts per item stay the same.

  • 400 g (14.11 oz) strong white bread flour, about 11–13% protein
  • 252 g (8.89 oz) water
  • 1 g (0.04 oz) instant yeast
  • 11 g (0.39 oz) fine salt, divided: 10 g for dough and 1 g for tomato
  • 8 g (0.28 oz) olive oil, for the dough
  • 4 g (0.14 oz) sugar
  • 180 g (6.35 oz) canned peeled tomatoes, crushed, with excess liquid drained
  • 240 g (8.47 oz) low-moisture mozzarella, made with microbial rennet
  • 12 g (0.42 oz) vegetarian hard cheese made with microbial rennet, finely grated
  • 0.6 g (less than 0.04 oz) dried oregano

Equipment

  • Large covered mixing bowl
  • scales
  • precision scales
  • two dough containers
  • refrigerator (4°C/39°F or colder)
  • steel or stone
  • large peel

Method

Before shaping or topping, divide the ingredients between 2 pizzas at their original size. Prepare each item as described. Do not multiply cooking times by the number of items. Extra batches still take extra time. Look for the doneness cues in the recipe.

  1. Knead a smooth dough with a little oil Mix flour, yeast and sugar. Work in 252 g cool water, then add 10 g salt and the oil. Knead for seven to nine minutes until smooth and extensible. Cover and begin fermentation for 45–60 minutes at about 22°C/72°F, folding once after 25 minutes.
  2. Cold-ferment for 24 hours Refrigerate in a roomy closed container for 24 hours at 4°C/39°F or colder. Allow room for expansion and keep the surface covered. This yeast dose is intended for this schedule, not three additional warm days.
  3. Shape and warm two dough balls Divide cold dough into two equal pieces of approximately 338 g/11.9 oz and round them. Rest covered for 90–120 minutes at about 22–24°C/72–75°F. During the final hour fully heat a stone or steel to 250°C/482°F conventional, or 230°C fan.
  4. Season tomato and weigh cheese Drain free liquid from tomatoes, crush them and stir in the remaining 1 g salt. Freshly grate mozzarella and combine with vegetarian hard cheese. Divide both tomato and cheese mixture into two equal portions.
  5. Open the first pizza wide and evenly Open only the first dough ball to 33–35 cm/13–14 in. Keep the centre thin and even, with a deliberately lower rim than a Neapolitan pizza. Transfer to the peel and check it slides.
  6. Top lightly and bake the first pizza Add one prepared portion each of tomato and cheese. Per pizza, crumble over 0.3 g oregano. Bake on the hot steel for 10–13 minutes until golden underneath and cooked at the centre. Move lower if cheese browns early.
  7. Let the surface recover and bake the remaining pizzas Transfer the first pizza to a rack. While the steel recovers for four to five minutes, open the next dough ball and add one prepared tomato portion and one cheese portion. Per pizza, use 0.3 g oregano. Bake every remaining base for 10–13 minutes and check it independently. The original schedule covers the original yield; extra pizzas require extra oven batches.
  8. Cut wide foldable slices Rest each pizza for three to five minutes and cut into six wide slices. The tip should support its cheese and the centre should fold gently for eating. A wet dense dough line under the cheese means more baking is needed.

Estimated nutrition

What is included
  • The estimate uses the stated ingredients, including oil that may remain in the pan.
  • Where a label reports an upper limit, the estimate uses that limit.
Nutrient½ pizza2 pizzas, each 33–35 cm / 13–14 in
Energy542 kcal2170 kcal
Protein26.7 g106.9 g
Carbohydrate72.5 g290.2 g
Fat15.3 g61.2 g
Salt3.45 g13.8 g

A cheese slice, not a pepperoni variation

This pizza has its own cold-fermented dough, a low foldable rim and an even cheese layer. A 63% hydration and a little oil support a thin continuous crumb. The recipe bakes two large pizzas in sequence, so both bakes are included in the schedule.

Why the cheese is not a solid blanket

Spread freshly grated low-moisture mozzarella thinly, leaving a few visible patches of tomato. The 240 g mozzarella is for both pizzas, not each one. Fresh mozzarella introduces more water and is not a straight swap.

Load a large pizza safely

Check that a 33–35 cm/13–14 in pizza fits your peel and baking surface before topping. A smaller surface requires smaller dough pieces and reassessed baking times. Let the steel recover between pizzas and keep the second ball covered until needed.

Re-crisp a slice

Reheat chilled slices thoroughly on a preheated tray at 190°C/374°F for roughly 6–9 minutes. Refrigerate leftovers within two hours and eat within two days at 4°C or colder. Use the raw dough after the stated 24-hour cold fermentation; extra days are not part of this yeast schedule.

Add a little smoked cheese

For a subtle smoky note, replace 40–60 g of the total 240 g mozzarella with low-moisture smoked mozzarella. Drain fresh brined cheese thoroughly and do not simply increase the quantity. Base nutrition uses the stated unsmoked low-moisture mozzarella.

Store leftovers safely

Refrigerate cooked leftovers within two hours, store in a shallow covered container at 4°C/39°F or colder and eat within two days. Reheat only what you need until hot throughout; 74°C/165°F at the centre is a clear target for reheated leftovers.

US measuring-cup equivalents

Weigh the flour and water.

More info: US measures

US volume equivalents are approximate: 400 g bread flour is about 3.33 US cups; 252 g water is about 1.07 US cups. The gram quantities define the recipe.

Rate this recipe

Rate the recipe after trying it. Your comment helps other cooks.

Loading ratings …

Comments are optional. By submitting a comment, you consent to public display of your text and any name you provide; you may withdraw this consent at any time for the future. The text is sent to OpenAI for abuse screening. Privacy and deletion.

Related recipes and help with baking

Oven Heat: Air Temperature versus Baking Surface · Opening Pizza Dough: Relax Tension and Preserve the Rim

All Pizza Recipes · Pizza and Coke: the Best Pairing for Every Style

If you like this combination

Guidance for the key steps

Plan the rest of pizza night

New York Cheese Pizza with Foldable Slices

Selected quantity: 2 pizzas

Original yield: 2 pizzas, each 33–35 cm / 13–14 in

250 °C / 482 °F conventional · 230 °C / 446 °F fan · Gas Mark approximately 9

2 pizzas · 1× original recipe

The ingredient list shows the totals for this selection. Amounts per item stay the same.

Before shaping or topping, divide the ingredients between 2 pizzas at their original size. Prepare each item as described. Do not multiply cooking times by the number of items. Extra batches still take extra time. Look for the doneness cues in the recipe.

Ingredients

  • 400 g (14.11 oz) strong white bread flour, about 11–13% protein
  • 252 g (8.89 oz) water
  • 1 g (0.04 oz) instant yeast
  • 11 g (0.39 oz) fine salt, divided: 10 g for dough and 1 g for tomato
  • 8 g (0.28 oz) olive oil, for the dough
  • 4 g (0.14 oz) sugar
  • 180 g (6.35 oz) canned peeled tomatoes, crushed, with excess liquid drained
  • 240 g (8.47 oz) low-moisture mozzarella, made with microbial rennet
  • 12 g (0.42 oz) vegetarian hard cheese made with microbial rennet, finely grated
  • 0.6 g (less than 0.04 oz) dried oregano

Allergens

Wheat (gluten), milk. Choose cheese made with microbial rennet for a vegetarian version.

Estimated nutrition

Nutrition½ pizzaSelected quantity
Energy542 kcal2,170 kcal
Protein26.7 g106.9 g
Carbohydrate72.5 g290.2 g
Fat15.3 g61.2 g
Salt3.45 g13.8 g

Method

  1. Knead a smooth dough with a little oil Mix flour, yeast and sugar. Work in 252 g cool water, then add 10 g salt and the oil. Knead for seven to nine minutes until smooth and extensible. Cover and begin fermentation for 45–60 minutes at about 22°C/72°F, folding once after 25 minutes.
  2. Cold-ferment for 24 hours Refrigerate in a roomy closed container for 24 hours at 4°C/39°F or colder. Allow room for expansion and keep the surface covered. This yeast dose is intended for this schedule, not three additional warm days.
  3. Shape and warm two dough balls Divide cold dough into two equal pieces of approximately 338 g/11.9 oz and round them. Rest covered for 90–120 minutes at about 22–24°C/72–75°F. During the final hour fully heat a stone or steel to 250°C/482°F conventional, or 230°C fan.
  4. Season tomato and weigh cheese Drain free liquid from tomatoes, crush them and stir in the remaining 1 g salt. Freshly grate mozzarella and combine with vegetarian hard cheese. Divide both tomato and cheese mixture into two equal portions.
  5. Open the first pizza wide and evenly Open only the first dough ball to 33–35 cm/13–14 in. Keep the centre thin and even, with a deliberately lower rim than a Neapolitan pizza. Transfer to the peel and check it slides.
  6. Top lightly and bake the first pizza Add one prepared portion each of tomato and cheese. Per pizza, crumble over 0.3 g oregano. Bake on the hot steel for 10–13 minutes until golden underneath and cooked at the centre. Move lower if cheese browns early.
  7. Let the surface recover and bake the remaining pizzas Transfer the first pizza to a rack. While the steel recovers for four to five minutes, open the next dough ball and add one prepared tomato portion and one cheese portion. Per pizza, use 0.3 g oregano. Bake every remaining base for 10–13 minutes and check it independently. The original schedule covers the original yield; extra pizzas require extra oven batches.
  8. Cut wide foldable slices Rest each pizza for three to five minutes and cut into six wide slices. The tip should support its cheese and the centre should fold gently for eating. A wet dense dough line under the cheese means more baking is needed.